Latest

Review: Claymore – Collector’s Edition

As a young girl, Clare was held prisoner by a body-snatching Yoma, forced to travel with him through village and town as a shield against monster hunters. She had become so tortured and withdrawn that she couldn’t speak. The day she met Teresa, she saw the same pain in her eyes and tried to comfort her, even as the townspeople looked on in silent dread. From then on, she would travel with Teresa as a companion and protector. Through her, Clare rediscovered her voice, and so to honour her, she would become the same half-Yoma that caused humans to fear her every step. She would choose to become a Claymore.

Created by the cult of the Organisation merely to quell the Yoma scourge, Claymores are contractors to humanity, much like the Witcher of Andrzej Sapkowski’s novels and the subsequent video games from CD Projekt RED. In fact, the one layer of separation from The Witcher here is that the only surviving Claymores are women. They are the fear of powerful women in the flesh, their strength withheld from fetish by disfigured bodies and impenetrable expressions. Clare is the bearer of a strange and fierce potential, the fear and rage that birthed it a wound too deep for humanity to comprehend. And so they fear her as they would any of her sisters, but she is no hero among her own kind. It’s perhaps this very fact that draws Raki to her as she’s hunting Yoma invaders in his town. When he is cast out after his brother is found to be a Yoma’s façade, the only way he can think to go is after Clare.

With this whinging, clingy but strangely endearing boy, Clare finds herself in the same position as Teresa all those years ago. Though she isn’t quite sure why, she wants to defend him from those who banished him just for being connected to a Yoma. As she comes to feel comfortable around him, she tells him of the Claymore’s nature, how they are doomed to succumb to their Yoma half. The story of her childhood, of Teresa, remains a secret. As does her determination to take revenge on Teresa’s killer, the “Awakened Being” Priscilla. Angelic and ancient, some like grand concepts of architecture, these demons complete Claymore’s rarest factor as a fantasy. The monster-slaying adventure frames many stories of women’s pain and women’s rage. It’s etched in the lines of their eyes, remaining by some magic of studio Madhouse’s animation even when their vacant gaze rests on humanity.

Male Claymores did once exist, but reached the limits of their control over their monster’s desires much faster than the females. The impermanence and low stakes in their pride and bloodlust builds the solid ground the women walk on in this show. But although combat sequences should be the proof, they are often the most poorly presented, restricting the levels to which these female characters can prove themselves in battle. Too often boring, slow or lacklustre in animation, their enemies fluctuate in intrigue, but the male adversaries are the worst offenders for blandness. Outside the Organisation, their invisible eyes following our heroines as they search for their truths, there was no need for any more male villains in the first place. It’s more rewarding to see the one-upmanship and camaraderie between the Claymores hasn’t been feminised, just as the female enemies aren’t force-fed a masculine ego of grit and muscle. The only male character who manages to break free of all the dullness in the end is Raki. He’s never quite likeable, but you understand all he means to Clare; a thread to keep her humanity and treasured bond with Teresa in her sights, if only in her mind’s eye.

Though she tries to escape her memory of it, Clare’s journey with her sisters explores the sacrifice that’s the rite of true humanity over monstrousness. A group of women who were made to believe they were mere beasts came together and uncovered their humanity through fighting side by side. Together, they march against the darkening shadow of the evil men who used their grief to bring them under control. Between all the violence as storytelling, that is the human heart of this sadly understated feminist fantasy.


Extras:

English dub; commentary on episodes 1, 8, 11, 16, 19 and 26; cast auditions; interviews with director Hiroyuki Tanaka, sound director Yasunori Honda, art director Manabu Otsuzuki, and art settings Nobuhito Sue; clean opening/closing animation; commercials and trailers.

11 Comments on Review: Claymore – Collector’s Edition

  1. I really enjoyed this series. I picked it up on a whim at a convention and definitely thought it was a good purchase. My only complaint was that I felt the ending was a cop-out.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Elisabeth O'Neill // February 1, 2017 at 6:14 pm // Reply

      I love it when great things happen by chance like that. As I’ve not read the manga, I can only guess that the ending for it goes beyond the end of the anime. I just wanted to see more, get to know all the new characters that only came through to fight Priscilla in the final few episodes.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Oh aye, I think that a further series with some proper time given to the newer characters would have been great. Regardless of any issues with the ending though, I did love the whole tone of the show. In some ways, it reminded me of the stuff I used to watch years ago.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved this anime but I kinda missed out on Raki’s endearing factor and only found him annoying. The ending too wasn’t as good as the story prior to it. Still a good show though.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. a) That post was beautifully written. ❤

    b) I am intrigued.

    c) This anime sounds really intense.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Still one of my absolute favourite manga of all time. I probably binge-read it once every two years. There are always tears.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Arcadia Pod

100% Nerd Stuff

The Kim Newman Web Site

writer. critic. broadcaster. journalist.

Feminist Fujoshi

consent consent and more consent

The Tiny World of an Anime Amateur

Thoughts and ramblings on anime, manga and visual novels

%d bloggers like this: